Protect What You've Built in Navajo County
Specialty insurance for landlords, contractors, ranch owners, and property investors throughout the White Mountains and Navajo County. Former contractors. 20+ years. Licensed all 50 states.
Specialty Insurance for Every Navajo County Need
From Show Low rental cabins to Holbrook commercial properties — we cover the insurance types that standard carriers often decline.
Landlord Insurance
Comprehensive coverage for your rental properties in Navajo County. Protect against tenant damage, liability, and lost rental income.
Learn More
Contractor Insurance
General liability and workers compensation tailored for Arizona contractors. Stay protected on every job site.
Learn MoreRental Property Insurance
Multi-unit and single-family rental coverage designed for Navajo County property investors.
Learn More
Commercial Property
Protect your business property, inventory, and equipment from fire, theft, and natural disasters.
Learn More
Farm & Ranch Insurance
Agricultural property, livestock, equipment, and liability coverage for Navajo County ranchers and farmers.
Learn More
Cabin & Vacation Property
Specialized coverage for White Mountains cabins, vacation rentals, and short-term rental properties.
Learn More
Outdoor Recreation Business
Insurance for Arizona adventure tourism, guide services, and outdoor recreation businesses.
Learn MoreWhy Choose Contractors Choice Agency?
We're not a generalist agency. We built our practice around specialty insurance for the types of properties and businesses that standard carriers struggle to cover properly.
Built by Former Contractors
Our founders spent years in the trades before becoming insurance specialists. We understand the real risks you face on job sites, rental properties, and ranches — because we've been there.
Specialty Market Access
We work with specialty carriers that understand unique Arizona property risks — wildfire exposure, altitude, seasonal rentals, and agricultural operations that standard insurers often decline.
Navajo County Focused
From Holbrook to Show Low, Winslow to the White Mountains — we know Navajo County's unique geography, economy, and insurance needs better than any national agency.
Serving All of Navajo County, Arizona
From the high desert plains around Holbrook and Winslow to the cool mountain forests of Show Low and Pinetop — we know every corner of Navajo County.
Licensed statewide in Arizona and all 50 states. Not in Navajo County? Contact us anyway — we likely serve your area.
Getting Covered is Simple
Three straightforward steps to specialty insurance coverage for your Navajo County property or business.
Tell Us About Your Property
Complete our simple online form or call us. We'll gather the key details about your property type, location, and coverage needs.
We Shop Specialty Markets
We access specialty carriers that understand Arizona's unique risks. We compare options to find the best coverage at the most competitive rates.
Get Covered, Stay Protected
Review your options, choose your coverage, and get your certificate of insurance. We handle the paperwork — you get peace of mind.
Trusted by Navajo County Property Owners
“I own 8 rental cabins in the White Mountains area and getting them insured was a nightmare with standard carriers. Contractors Choice Agency found me a specialty policy that actually covers everything I needed.”
“As a contractor in Navajo County, I needed liability coverage that matched the type of work we do. CCA understood exactly what I needed and got me covered quickly. Highly recommend.”
“Our cattle ranch had some unique coverage needs that most agents couldn't handle. The team at Contractors Choice knew the agricultural insurance market and found us exactly the right policy.”
Latest from Our Blog
The Complete Guide to Landlord Insurance in Navajo County, AZ
Everything Navajo County property owners need to know about landlord insurance — from coverage requirements to finding the right policy.
Contractor Insurance Requirements in the White Mountains Area
Arizona contractors face unique risks. Here's what coverage you need to stay compliant and protected in Navajo County.
Cabin Rental Insurance for Show Low Area Property Owners
Your standard homeowners policy won't cover vacation rental income. Learn what White Mountains cabin owners really need.
Get Your Free Quote Today
Whether you're a landlord in Show Low, a contractor in Snowflake, or a rancher near Holbrook — we have specialty coverage designed for your Navajo County operation. Get a quote in minutes.